Speeding Up the Plow Horse
First Trust Advisors
By Brian Wesbury, Bob Stein
June 4, 2012
We call it a Plow Horse Economyâ€¦it ainâ€™t gonna win the Belmont, but it ainâ€™t gonna keel over and die, either. And there is nothing in the latest data or market action that changes our mind; the economy is not in recession and we highly doubt it will fall into one anytime soon.
The Pouting Pundits of Pessimism are hyperventilating over the weaker-than-expected 69,000 increase in May payrolls, a downward revision in first quarter real GDP growth to 1.9%, a 10-year Treasury yield of 1.5%, and a stock market that has given up its gains for the year.
Back in the winter months, when the payroll numbers were relatively robust, the pessimists complained about a declining labor force. But now they ignore that the labor force rose by 642,000, while the participation rate rose to 63.8% from 63.6% in April. Not very consistent of them, eh?
That wasnâ€™t the only area of the jobs report that defied the pessimists. The household survey (which captures small businesses) reported 422,000 new jobs. This was not enough to overcome the huge gain in the labor force, so the unemployment rate ticked up to 8.2%. But the acceleration in the household number suggests the job market is not as bad as it was made out to be.
We also heard that 70% of the time an economy slows to below 2% real GDP growth a recession follows. We arenâ€™t quite sure what this is supposed to mean. If someone can show us an economy that didnâ€™t fall through 2% growth on the way to recession we will give them a million new Drachma. Regardless, recent revisions to construction data suggest real GDP growth gets revised back up above 2% for Q1.
So why do we have a Plow Horse economy and not a Race Horse economy? The answers are simpleâ€¦theyâ€™re the same reasons Europe had slow growth and a high unemployment rate for the past three decades: government spending, taxes, and regulation have been a huge burden. Think of a race horse carrying a 250 lb. jockey or a plow horse dragging the plow through stumps and roots in a field. Government is a burden which slows growth and reduces job opportunities. The only way to get a permanent acceleration â€“ in real GDP, incomes, and job growth â€“ is to lighten the load. The good news for the US is that there is a four step plan to make this happen and weâ€™re going to face all of them this year.
First is the recall election on Tuesday for Scott Walker as Governor of Wisconsin. Democrats in Massachusetts and Rhode Island â€“ even Rahm Emanuel in Chicago â€“ have also carried out reforms for government workers, but Walkerâ€™s efforts created a massive political backlash. A Walker victory would set the stage for more reforms in other states.
Second is the late June Supreme Court ruling on Obamacare. Health insurance is an important issue and many reasonable people disagree about inequities in that market, but a government takeover would signal further growth in government spending and regulation, which would dampen the entrepreneurial spirit and increase uncertainty.
Third is the November 7th presidential election, when voters across the country get the chance to signal a desire to roll back the size and scope of government. â€śCoreâ€ť government spending â€“ outside of defense, TARP, interest and entitlements â€“ has hit a record high in recent years. A change in leadership would mean a chance to greatly reduce the share of GDP controlled by Washington. Finally, the scheduled tax hike on income, capital gains, and dividends in 2013 has become a wall of uncertainty for business to overcome. If the first three steps happen, this one will too.
These steps will decide whether the US heads toward a European-like future or remains a bastion of free market capitalism. As each step unfolds, the momentum of the decisions will also become more visible. We remain confident America is a â€ścenter-rightâ€ť country that respects its Constitution. If so, look out. The Plow Horse may turn into a thoroughbred.
This information contains forward-looking statements about various economic trends and strategies. You are cautioned that such forward-looking statements are subject to significant business, economic and competitive uncertainties and actual results could be materially different. There are no guarantees associated with any forecast and the opinions stated here are subject to change at any time and are the opinion of the individual strategist. Data comes from the following sources: Census Bureau, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Bureau of Economic Analysis, the Federal Reserve Board, and Haver Analytics. Data is taken from sources generally believed to be reliable but no guarantee is given to its accuracy.
(c) First Trust Advisors